Review: ‘Paranormal Activity’

In the tradition of Blair Witch, Paranormal Activity creates a prison without bars that lets the audience experience the walls closing in along with the victims.

Katie and Micah are just an average couple that seems to be getting a good start on life in a nice home. The documentary-style film, cobbled together from home video taped by Micah, reveals early on that the couple suspects the house may be haunted or that an entity of some sort is trying to get their attention. As funny noises slowly escalate into tangible events, facts surrounding the haunting emerge and escalate the uncertainty. Calling out the suspected entity responsible for going bump in the night probably wasn’t a good idea, either…

If you haven’t seen Paranormal Activity and truly want the full, undiluted experience, stop reading HERE. It’s nearly impossible to talk about this movie without hinting at things that diminish its effectiveness. If, on the other hand, you’re still reading, then you have either seen it already or are fairly sure knowing if it’s actually real or not will not ruin your viewing. Still here? Read on…

The first question many people will be asking is, is it better or worse than The Blair Witch Project? Yes… and no. In the inevitable comparison of low budget filmmaking, Blair Witch invented more of its own mythology (which makes it harder to debunk or dismiss.) Paranormal Activity uses well-known occult props (such as a witch board) along with questionable effects that undermine the more effective bits when we’re not sure what to really expect before something happens. At least the visiting psychic didn’t pull out a deck of tarot cards and walk in a goat.

But Paranormal Activity trumps Blair Witch in utilizing its intimate space and genre. It’s a haunted house film, plain and simple, but with practical effects rather than Liam Neeson cowering at green screened monsters. The editing keeps the story unfolding in a way that heightens the discomfort of being trapped inside to endure whatever we’re afraid is about to jump out and menace the couple on screen. The absence of any musical queues means that the audience response is organic; viewers have a moment’s preview for what’s coming for the couple onscreen just long enough to worry about it.

Shot for $11,500 (including camera, computer, editing software, actors salaries and catering), at least four endings were planned. It has been reported that the theatrical version’s ending was suggested by Steven Spielberg (and it’s pretty effective) while the original ending is out on the web (and will likely appear on the eventual DVD.) Paramount originally purchased this Indie feature to remake as a studio film, then thankfully decided to let word of mouth and a slow release into theaters do their work for them. Whether it scares you or not, Paranormal Activity is further proof that even the studios are starting to learn that effective film-making and huge returns doesn’t necessarily require huge budgets to begin with.

(a four skull recommendation out of four)


  1. I must say I am surprised this film rates a very rare “four skulls”; not because of the film itself (which I admit I haven’t seen) but due to the unfortunate comparison to the Blair Witch.

    After a pair of Science Fiction movies (unnamed to save them embarrassment) the Blair Witch was the third most boring disappointment I’ve ever wasted my money on.

    When it came out, I heard that “grown men had thrown up and/or left the theater” during the film. I have to ask: who are these “grown men”? They are a disgrace to testosterone. Blair Witch was nothing but a collection of aborted story attempts masquerading as a reality show about young city “kids” getting lost in the woods while squabbling over cigarettes.

    I could go on and on about how awful Blair Witch was and why, but this is a post about Paranormal Activity, so I won’t … for now.

    My point is this: comparing films can be a risky business if one is trying to recommend the film at hand. For me, the moment anyone compares anything to the Blair Witch, that’s the moment that I decide not to waste more of my money on the new film. Maybe that’s not entirely fair to the new film, but I was too bored and annoyed by the comparison film to give it a fair chance.

    To this day, I cannot understand how anyone thought the Blair Witch was scary. The most frightening part for me was how it went on and on with almost nothing actually happening in between fights over maps and smokes (not to mention that oft-lampooned snot bubble – yuk).

    Paranormal Activity may or may not be worth my time and money – but if it really is anything like Blair Witch, I won’t bother to find out.


Speak up, Mortal -- and beware of Spoilers!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s